The threats are bogus. The material is protected parody, not an infringement.

What you'll enjoy far more is My response to their threat.

April 9, 2001

Mr. Brad Templeton

NETFUNNY.COM

<Address Redacted>

RE: MasterCard/Infringement by NETFUNNY.COM web site

Dear Mr. Templeton:

We are the attorneys for MasterCard International ("MasterCard").

Since at least as early 1998, MasterCard has aired a series of television and print advertisements that feature the names and/or images of a series of goods or services purchased by one or more individuals and which, with either voice-overs and/or other visual displays, convey to the viewer the price of each of these items (the "MasterCard Priceless Advertisements"). At the end of each of the MasterCard Priceless Advertisements a phrase identifying some priceless intangible that cannot be purchased (such as "a day where all you have to do is breathe") is followed by the word and/or voice over: "priceless". Immediately following "priceless" are the words and/or voice overs: there are some things money can't buy, for everything else there's MasterCard".

Additionally, MasterCard is the owner of U.S. service mark registrations for the marks "PRICELESS" (Reg. No. 2,370,508); "THERE ARE SOME THINGS MONEY CAN'T BUY, FOR EVERYTHING ELSE THERE'S MASTERCARD" (Reg. No. 2,259,941); and THERE ARE SOME THINGS MONEY CAN'T BUY. FOR EVERYTHING ELSE THERE'S MASTERCARD." (Reg. No. 2,297,299) (collectively, the "Priceless Marks"). Indeed, MasterCard has applied for protection of all of these marks in numerous countries throughout the world. As a result of MasterCard's extensive advertising, the Priceless Marks have become associated exclusively with MasterCard's financial services products. Furthermore, MasterCard owns multiple U.S. copyright registrations for the Priceless Advertisements.

MasterCard is also the owner of multiple federal registrations for MASTERCARD (unstylized) (the "MASTERCARD Mark"). The MASTERCARD Mark has long been featured in MasterCard advertising, including the MasterCard Priceless Advertisements. As a result of its long and continued use, the MASTERCARD Mark has become widely recognized as identifying MasterCard's financial services products.

It has come to our attention that you are distributing at the URL www.netfunny.com/rhf/jokes/Apr/columbine.html material that infringes the MasterCard Priceless Advertisements and that further infringes MasterCard's MASTERCARD Mark and Priceless Marks. This material (the "Infringing Material ") blatantly copies the sequential display of a series of items belonging to one or more individuals, showing, the "price" of each item, and, at the end, infringes, with impunity, the MASTERCARD Mark and the Priceless Marks.

Specifically, the Infringing Material is entitled PRICELESS, followed by a series of text, "200 rounds of ammo: $70; Two ski masks: $24; Two black trench coats: $260; the look on your classmates faces right before you blow their heads off -- priceless" and concludes with the MasterCard's slogan, for which it owns a U.S. trademark registration: "There are some things money can't buy, for everything else there's MasterCard."

Please be advised that in publishing the Infringing Material, you have infringed MasterCard's rights under the federal and state trademark and unfair competition laws, under the federal and state anti-dilution laws, and under the Copyright Act. The fact that your actions take place in the context of the sad events at Columbine merely exacerbates the problem from our client's viewpoint. The Infringing Material denigrates the tragedy at Columbine High School and holds our client out as sponsoring this highly distasteful material by using the format of the MasterCard Priceless Advertisements and prominently displaying MasterCard's famous trademarks.

Accordingly, we demand that you confirm immediately and no later than Friday, April 13, 2001, that you will remove the Infringing Material from the web site www.netfunny.com and that there will be no further publication of the Infringing Material or any other material which infringes MasterCard's rights as set forth above.

This letter does not constitute an exhaustive statement of MasterCard's legal position nor is it a waiver of any of their rights and/or remedies in this or any other matter.

Very truly yours,

Russell H. Falconer

212.408.2564

FAX 212.705.5020

russell.falconer@bakerbotts.com

30 ROCKEFELLER PLAZA 44TH FLOOR NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10112-0228

bcc: Colm Dobbyn, Esq.

Crystal Howard, Esq.

RHF Home | Current Jokes | Best of Jokes | Search